I found this article on a vegan forum I frequent today. There is a whole breed of people who occupy themselves by going onto forums to get everyone rilled up. You know who I am talking about. Those that go on vegan forums to say that they had the most delicious pigeon steak today! You know…Jerks.
Anyways, someone posted this link as a reason not to be vegan: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/scotland/article4087977.ece
The story is about a 12 year old vegan girl who has the spine of an elderly woman because of a lack of Vitamin D through her childhood diet. The parents will likely be brought to social services for neglecting the needs of their child. Included in the article was also a story about a 10 month old girl who died because her parents were feeding her nothing but breast milk, raw fruit, juice and nuts. They are awaiting a sentence for her murder and are facing jail time.
The forum was a flurry of outrage. Some of the responders complained about how the media is constantly victimizing vegans and how the media never misses an opportunity to bash vegans yet they never talk about obesity and other carnivorous problems.
Well, none of that is true. The truth is there are bucket loads of news stories about those very things. It is true that the media will always be biased towards the dairy industries (who are strong lobbyist and valuable advertisers with lots of government support), but there is no real persecution there. Many associations (like the Heart and Stroke Foundation and the diabetes one) have supported vegetarian diets as a way of reducing these diseases and maintaining a healthier weight.
The article was quite harsh about vegan diets but I think it did more good than harm. The families described in these incidents are “hardliners.” Probably leaning towards the raw food movement. This is ABSOLUTELY inappropriate for infants and children. Children need a diet higher in fat than adults do and they need decent sources of protein (not derived from walnuts). It’s great to have ethics, but at what cost?
In the article is this quote: “A spokesman [of a vegan association] said: “I would suggest that it is not the vegan diet itself \ but the parents.” “
I agree with this.
I think that a vegan diet can be healthy for children but it requires planning. In this pregnancy I had started drinking milk but couldn’t bring myself to keep it up after I started thinking about what was in the milk. I read that vegan moms have a higher risk of having a baby with hypospadias (a minor penis deformity) as a result of the phytoestrogens in soy products. So I am cutting way back on soy. I am trying to make sure that we aren’t getting more than one serving of a soy product per day.
My kids are on an all natural multi-vitamins and I also use a vegan friendly Essential Fatty Acid supplement (Udo’s Oil 3.6.9) in their diet. I try to make sure that they are getting the best go at life without compromising my ethics too much. My boys are, afterall, my number one priority.
And it seems to be working. They are bright and alert. They are as big and active as their peers and they have strong immune systems.
I see this article as an education for myself as a parent. To continue to evaluate their diet. Or rather, a confirmation that I am on the right track.
To see a more balanced look there is also this news clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rYX18NGTwls This is a CNN news clip that does a good job of showing how a vegan diet reduces your carbon foot print and lowers you overall caloric intake without reducing the tastiness of your meals.
Anyways, here is to moderation and vegan chocolate cake!